FightingSeraph's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Creasman]

Surprisingly catchy.

I see where you're coming from regarding the author's comments: I first came here in 2000, signed up in 2001, but haven't submitted anything until this year. Truth is, I'm not much of a music critic, which is why don't usually write reviews for music submissions.

Instrumentwise, I like the variety that you have going here for this piece. Kind of reminds me of the Sega game Rez. In terms of composition, it may take some getting used to, but once you do get used to it; it becomes very catchy. As for ambiance, while it may not be up there with Nanashi's latest AP songs; I can see this being used as some sort of sound cues.

What I do like:
-Catchy
-Original
-Nice instrumentation and composition

What I don't like:
-Takes time to get used to.
-May not be up to everyone's tastes.

Overall: For a first audio submission, this is one of the better beginnings. Here's a nine out of ten, and keep practicing.

Xalkie responds:

Thanks for the feedback. ^-^ I'll try my best with later submissions. I'm still learning allot so thanks for the understanding. Here it to hoping I can get my comp back up to standards soon to make more musacs.

[Waiting For Light]

Pretty epic!

This really sounds like something that you would hear from Star Ocean, R-Type, The Lemmings Chronicles, or a really obscure anime. This song really proves that you can do something original, and you're usually synonymous with Robotech flash. (Nothing wrong with that as long as it's not the only kind of stuff that you do.) With that out of the way...

In terms of instrumentation, you did a great job selecting various string and brass instruments, which can make or break a song in my book. Truth is, I prefer music that sets moods/atmospheres rather than those that tell stories/convey messages. Then there's the composition, which is really impressive. I usually don't write reviews for music very often, but I think all that time making arranged Robotech music has paid off.

What I do like:
-Great composition
-Nice instrument selection
-Original, but the execution must work in order for that to be worth something. (And it did in this case.)

What I don't like:
-Nothing at the moment

Overall: You definitely have the composition skills worthy of being in many flash movies. Army Ranger/Nanashi, here's a ten out of ten!

Nanashi responds:

Wow, that is one hell of a review. Thanks! While I'm appreciative of reviews that say 'Awesomez! 10!' (Normally on my flash, not my music), it means a whole lot more when someone actually explains WHY something is good or bad, and I'm not just saying this because you had no cons this time.

If I had been getting this kind of feedback from the start, I think I'd be a lot further along. Again, thanks for your time and words.

[10,000 Jiggies]

Badass!

It's been a long while since I listened to any new heavy metal rock, and as I said before, it's pretty fucking badass! Truth is, I'm not into reviewing music when compared to flash movies and art, but I know good Audio Portal music when I hear it. With that out of the way...

In terms of singing, it blows Francine Louise and Hania Lee out of the water. Even though the latter has something in terms of actual singing skills, almost all of her songs sound exactly the same. I was really into it and the lyrics were awesome! Plus, I like how you put in the original theme in there, and it also helps that I'm a fan of both of the N64 Banjo-Kazooie games. Then there's the instrumentation, which can make or break a song (check out TFX's songs to see what I mean). I mean, were those actual guitars and drums used? If not, I won't hold it against you because you're just one man. Plus, the composition and timing to the lyrics remind me of '80s metal meets GWAR. (I wish that there were more Gwar flash on here.)

What I do like:
-Cool lyrics
-Excellent singing
-Kickass instrumentation and composition
-Inclusion of the original theme song

What I don't like:
-Short, but if it were longer, that would ruin it.

Overall: Druox the Shredder, how would you like a ten for this?

DruoxtheShredder responds:

The guitars are real, the drums are not.

[Creepy Song for Creepy Game]

More annoying than creepy.

TFX, it's been a long time since you last submitted something here, but this wasn't very good. Look, even though I loved your Zero Wing flash when you first created it back in 2001; you pretty much went to shit after 2005 with that Musical Interpretation cartoon. Not to mention, I hate giving bad reviews, especially without a valid reason, but...

In terms of instrumentation, it sounds similar to the samples used in Cave Story and La Mulana, but unfortunately the composition was pretty poor and seemed like you were playing random notes aimlessly. I think some classical music traning for you is in order. Dude, a lot has changed since you submitted that Zero Wing remake in 2003 and while your '05 stuff was good; you are facing stiff competition with Druox the Shredder, Krinkels (who has expanded beyond Madness), Evil-Dog (Punk-o-Matic, Freak), Rick Marin (Primal War), YungJazz (Devilslayer and Necropolis), Nemesis Theory, Sam Haft, Paragon X9, and a whole lot of others. In short, you had an idea for something fresh, but the way it was done is more annoying than creepy.

What I do like:
-Good idea
-Not a remix of an existing song

What I don't like:
-Bad composition and arrangement
-Wouldn't fit in any horror game.

Overall: While this would normally warrant a three or a four from me, I'm going to let you slide with a five out of ten.

TFX responds:

Oh, I didn't know someone had actually replied! I appreciate your review.

The reason why I haven't sent up anything is I haven't had anything worthy of sending up. I know the competition is stiff, don't you worry. Musical Interpretation was just a silly thing.

Thanks again!

[Music Box Retreat]

Catchy and atmospheric!

I really like the instrumental selection and the composition of this piece; it has a Tales of Phantasia-esque feel to it. For a first song, this is actually better than most people's first songs that were done on a computer (or actual instruments for that matter). Truth is, I usually don't review music often, but due to the paltry ammount of reviews this has; I just had to say what I have to say.

What I do like:
-Nice instrument choices
-Great composition
-Something new and original

What I don't like:
-The fact that this song hasn't been used in any flash movies.

Overall: Helbereth, how would you like a ten for this underappreciated gem of a song?

Helbereth responds:

Thank you, sir (guessing on the sir part).

I kinda forgot I'd even made this. Hearing it again it kinda reminds me of Earthbound in a way. It was fun to make, but I'm really not a musician. Still the praise is appreciated.

[Madness 6.5]

Musical excellence!!

Cheshyre, this was fucking awesome in ways that few, if any, can comprehend. I usually don't review music very often, but this is the first time I reviewed a piece from you. With that out of the way...

I like the nice pace that this song has, along with the build ups and other wise choices that you and Krinkels have done. Truth is, I like music that sets moods/atmospheres rather than those that tell stories, and this is coming from someone who likes metal. Plus, I like the individual sounds that you chose, which added to the mood this song, along with the cartoon itself. This is one song that is definitely going into my favorites, but the only problem is the filesize, which will put off those on narrowband connections.

What I like:
-The sound selection
-Nice use of buildups
-Good pacing
-Great atmosphere for what it was meant for

What I don't like:
-The filesize is rather big

Overall: How would you like a ten out of ten, Cheshyre?

cheshyre responds:

I would love it! Thank a bunch! Sorry about the file size, I'll try and keep them down from now on

[Forest_Density [Box-Killa]]

Not bad, I like it.

I rarely write music reviews here because that isn't my specialty. I can see something like this being used in an RPG of some sort. However, some of the 'darker' parts of the song seemed to drag.

What I like:
-Versatle (can be used in either a game or a movie).
-Well-instrumented

What I didn't like:
-The moodier parts tended to drag.

Overall: Here's an eight from someone who hasn't done a music review in a long time.

Box-Killa responds:

Hmm im not quite sure what well instrumented means exactly. Good instrument choice? The moodier parts are the same in length as the happy parts by the way. Yes to everything else. Thanks for the 8, hope you review more songs now!